State Public Service Commission

The State Public Service Commission (SPSC) is the state-level counterpart of the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC). Both institutions draw their authority from the same set of constitutional provisions — Articles 315 to 323 under Part XIV. These articles collectively govern the composition, appointment and removal of members, functions, and independence of SPSCs across states.

---

• A SPSC consists of a chairman and other members, all appointed by the Governor of the concerned state.
• The Constitution does not fix the strength of the Commission; this is left to the Governor's discretion.
• No prescribed qualifications for membership exist, except that at least one-half of the members must have served for a minimum of ten years under either the Central Government or any State Government.
• The Governor also determines the conditions of service of the chairman and members.

Tenure

• Members hold office for six years or until they reach 62 years of age, whichever comes earlier.
• Compare: For the UPSC, the age limit is 65 years.
• Members may resign voluntarily at any time by writing to the Governor.

Acting Chairman

The Governor may designate one of the sitting members as Acting Chairman in two situations:

1. When the chairman's post falls vacant.
2. When the chairman is unable to discharge functions due to absence or any other reason.

The Acting Chairman continues until a new chairman is appointed or the original chairman resumes duties.

---

Despite being appointed by the Governor, the chairman and members of a SPSC can only be removed by the President — not by the Governor. This is a key constitutional safeguard.

Grounds for Removal by the President

The President can remove a chairman or member under the following circumstances:

• (a) If the person is adjudged insolvent (declared bankrupt).
• (b) If the person undertakes paid employment outside official duties during the term of office.
• (c) If the President considers the person unfit to continue on account of physical or mental infirmity.

Note: The Supreme Court ruled in 1993 that appointing a visually impaired professor as SPSC member cannot be invalidated merely on grounds of physical infirmity.

Removal for Misbehaviour

• For misbehaviour, the President must refer the matter to the Supreme Court for an inquiry.
• If the Supreme Court's inquiry upholds the cause of removal, the President must act on that advice — it is constitutionally binding.
• During the pendency of the Supreme Court inquiry, the Governor may suspend the concerned chairman or member.

Definition of Misbehaviour

A member is deemed guilty of misbehaviour if he/she:

• Is directly or indirectly interested in any contract or agreement made by the Government of India or any State Government, or
• Derives any benefit or profit from such a contract, except in the capacity of a shareholder in a public incorporated company (on equal terms with other shareholders).

---

The Constitution provides several guarantees to ensure the SPSC functions in an independent and impartial manner:

Post-Retirement Employment Rules

• Chairman of SPSC (after leaving office): Eligible to be appointed as chairman or member of the UPSC, or as chairman of any other SPSC. Not eligible for any other employment under the Central or any State Government.
• Member of SPSC (after leaving office): Eligible to become chairman or member of the UPSC, chairman of the same or any other SPSC. Not eligible for any other government employment.

These restrictions ensure members cannot be influenced during their tenure by the prospect of post-retirement favours from the government.

---

The SPSC performs for state services what the UPSC does for Central services.

(A) Recruitment

• Conducts examinations for appointments to state civil services and posts.

(B) Consultation on Personnel Matters

The government is required to consult the SPSC on:

1. Methods of recruitment to civil services and civil posts.
2. Principles for appointments, promotions, and transfers across services.
3. Suitability of candidates for appointments, promotions, transfers, and deputation.
4. Disciplinary matters affecting civil servants, including:
   • Censure
   • Withholding of increments or promotions
   • Recovery of pecuniary loss
   • Demotion to a lower rank or service
   • Compulsory retirement
   • Removal from service
   • Dismissal from service (Note: Dismissal, unlike removal, disqualifies the person from future government employment.)
5. Reimbursement of legal expenses to civil servants sued for acts done in the discharge of official duties.
6. Pension claims for injuries sustained during service under the state.
7. Any other personnel-related matters referred by the government.

Important judicial ruling: The Supreme Court has held that failure to consult the SPSC does not automatically invalidate a government decision. The consultation requirement is directory, not mandatory. Similarly, selection by the SPSC does not confer a legal right to the post — the government must act fairly but retains final discretion.

(C) Extended Functions

• The state legislature may confer additional functions on the SPSC relating to state services.
• It can also bring the personnel systems of local authorities, corporate bodies, or public institutions within the SPSC's jurisdiction.

(D) Annual Report

• The SPSC submits an annual performance report to the Governor.
• The Governor places the report before both Houses of the state legislature, along with a memorandum explaining cases where the Commission's advice was not accepted and the reasons for such non-acceptance.

---

Certain matters are explicitly outside the SPSC's consultative jurisdiction:

1. Reservations for backward classes — The SPSC need not be consulted when making reservations in appointments for any backward class of citizens.
2. Claims of SCs and STs — Consultation is not required when taking into account the claims of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in appointments.

Exclusion by Governor

• The Governor may, by regulation, specify matters for which SPSC consultation is not necessary.
• All such regulations must be laid before each House of the state legislature for at least 14 days.
• The state legislature has the power to amend or repeal such regulations.

---

The Constitution envisions the SPSC as the 'watchdog of the merit system' in the state.

What the SPSC does:

• Recruits for state services.
• Advises on promotions and disciplinary matters when consulted.

What the SPSC does NOT handle:

• Classification of services
• Pay and service conditions
• Cadre management
• Training

These functions belong to the Department of Personnel or the General Administration Department. Hence, while the SPSC is the central recruiting agency, the Department of Personnel is the central personnel agency in the state.

Advisory nature: SPSC recommendations are not binding. The state government can accept or reject them, but must explain departures from SPSC advice to the state legislature. The government may also frame rules limiting the scope of the SPSC's advisory functions (called SPSC Exemption from Consultation Regulations).

State Vigilance Commission (SVC): Established in 1964, the SVC is also consulted in disciplinary matters. When the SPSC and SVC give conflicting advice, the SPSC has an advantage as it is an independent constitutional body unlike the SVC.

Judicial appointments: The Governor consults the SPSC (and the concerned High Court) while framing rules for appointments to the judicial service of the state, excluding posts of district judges.

---

Creation

• A JSPSC may be established to serve two or more states jointly.
• Unlike the UPSC and SPSC (which are directly created by the Constitution), a JSPSC is created by an Act of Parliament on the request of the concerned state legislatures.
• Therefore, a JSPSC is a statutory body, not a constitutional body.

Historical example: Punjab and Haryana shared a JSPSC for a brief period after Haryana was carved out of Punjab in 1966.

Key Features of JSPSC

UPSC Serving State Needs

The UPSC can also be extended to serve the needs of a state, if the state Governor requests and the President approves.

---

• The Government of India Act, 1919 first provided for a Central Public Service Commission, which was set up in 1926.
• The Government of India Act, 1935 established a Federal Public Service Commission, Provincial Public Service Commissions, and provision for Joint Public Service Commissions for two or more provinces.

---

---

• Age limit trap: SPSC members retire at 62; UPSC members at 65.
• Appointment vs. Removal asymmetry: Appointed by Governor; removed only by the President.
• JSPSC vs. SPSC: SPSC is a constitutional body; JSPSC is a statutory body created by Parliament.
• Binding nature of SPSC advice: It is only advisory — not mandatory on the government.
• SC ruling on consultation: Non-consultation does not invalidate government action — it is directory, not mandatory.
• Post-retirement bar: SPSC members cannot hold any other government employment after demitting office — only specific PSC roles are permitted.
• Misbehaviour inquiry: Referred to the Supreme Court; SC's advice is binding on the President.
• Removal vs. Dismissal: Removal does not bar future government employment; dismissal does.